If this is your first visit, be sure to
check out the FAQ by clicking the
link above. You may have to register
before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages,
select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Nope can't go along with that. I give the man credit for his efforts in making his videos, he puts a lot of effort into them. But this test was flawed big time.
You can't test a two part epoxy product, like JB weld against all the other one part products he did. The two part epoxy will win every time, no contest, as seen in the video.
There are plenty of slow cure two part epoxy products out there, metalset, fastweld 10, etc. . that he could have used.
Nothing wrong with JB weld, but there are better out there if you know what to look for.
Yes you are right, it is an epoxy product and presumably it's strength can also be improved upon by proper temperature curing if the project allows.
But I think his approach was to generally test popular glues out there on their claims that they stick together various materials, everyday repairs if you like.
Nevertheless it is good that he has gone to such trouble, so it is informative. Not sure why you would glue a bolt, a different class of strength needed, only an amateur (ignorant person) would contemplate that. On that vein who would glue down an engine head? I was surprised by the instant fail though (which one was the JBWeld?.
Just looks like a rigged advertisement to me, no different to motors pulling competitors backwards or anything else, you set the "tests" and products to suit the desired outcome, any glue/epoxy is a patch, plain and simple, some patches last longer than others, but, nothing is better than a repair.
Nope can't go along with that. I give the man credit for his efforts in making his videos, he puts a lot of effort into them. But this test was flawed big time.
You can't test a two part epoxy product, like JB weld against all the other one part products he did. The two part epoxy will win every time, no contest, as seen in the video.
There are plenty of slow cure two part epoxy products out there, metalset, fastweld 10, etc. . that he could have used.
Nothing wrong with JB weld, but there are better out there if you know what to look for.
Compare apples to apples...he didn't do that.
Agreed with the above however, JB weld is easily found (at least down here), the others you posted above, never heard of them (nor seen them in any store).
I suppose you could order on-line what you posted above but if JB weld works well, and it's easily available, I'm going to use that..
Scott
1997 Angler 204, Center Console powered by a 2006 Yamaha F150TXR
I like his videos. They seem to be honest and fair in the way he regulates the tests.
For this one, I agree that the products compared are not equal. But I think that was the point. Some of these "TV Special" products make rather glorious claims and the purpose of the video was to test just how good those claims were compared to other "professional" (for lack of a better term) products. Another good two-part is MarineTex and PC-11, which I've used in the marine industry for decades.
marine tex is a pain to mix.
JB is simple and works well.
I just JB'd an upper case on a merc-loser that is warped at the lower to upper oil transfer hole.
I will file it down Monday and save the upper.
best two part I ever used was a product called Red Hand.
I bet no one here has ever heard of it.
BTW that was about 1969.
marine tex is a pain to mix.
JB is simple and works well.
I just JB'd an upper case on a merc-loser that is warped at the lower to upper oil transfer hole.
I will file it down Monday and save the upper.
best two part I ever used was a product called Red Hand.
I bet no one here has ever heard of it.
BTW that was about 1969.
Comment